Breaking
Loading headlines…
AI Business Dispatch.

Trading Standards Draws the Line on 'Housefishing' as DMCC Act Gives CMA New Teeth

Estate agents using AI to digitally furnish rooms, erase chimney breasts and airbrush defects now face a clear regulatory red line after Trading Standards issued guidance this week. The DMCC Act 2024 has handed the CMA enforcement powers the old consumer-protection rules lacked.

O
Olivia Lett · Today · 3 min read
Share:·X·LinkedIn
Trading Standards Draws the Line on 'Housefishing' as DMCC Act Gives CMA New Teeth
Olivia Lett

The Regulator Enters the Frame

Five months of simmering industry controversy crystallised on 16 November when Trading Standards issued formal guidance on what it calls acceptable and unacceptable AI use in property listings, responding directly to a BBC investigation that coined the term "housefishing" for the practice of digitally reimagining homes to a standard their bricks simply cannot match.

The guidance draws a workable distinction: AI can remove distracting personal belongings, virtually furnish an empty room or make basic photographic enhancements. What it cannot do is alter the structural characteristics of a property or create an impression materially different from what a viewer will find at the door. Marketing material must make clear AI has been used, and that the photograph does not necessarily represent the room as it appears. That last clause matters. It is not enough to bury a disclosure in white text on a white background, as one Winkworth franchise was found to have done in June.

Advertisement

TrademarkDashboard: Don't let someone else file your name before you do.

What the Law Now Says

The legal weight behind that guidance has changed. The Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers (DMCC) Act 2024 came into force on 6 April 2025, replacing the Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations 2008. Section 226 of the Act prohibits misleading actions, covering false or misleading information and deceptive overall presentation. The CMA's own guidance document, CMA207, explicitly treats the decision "whether to view a property" as a transactional decision, judged by its effect on the average consumer.

That framing has teeth. An AI-rendered interior that prompts a buyer or renter to travel across the city for a viewing, only to find peeling walls and missing fixtures, can in principle breach the rules regardless of a buried disclaimer. A small disclosure notice does not automatically correct a misleading overall impression.

The Agents in the Crosshairs

The BBC's investigation, published 13–14 November, documented buyers and renters discovering properties that bore little resemblance to their online listings. One buyer described arriving to find "no painted walls, no Matisse artwork, no fitted kitchen" after responding to an AI-staged listing. Leyla Ledwith, quoted in the report, called it "totally off-putting and really frustrating", noting that it wastes time for everyone in the chain: renters, buyers, sellers, landlords and agents alike.

Winkworth's Tooting franchise became the highest-profile case. AI images had added furniture and lighting to vacant rooms; one photograph removed a chimney breast entirely. The images were taken down after buyer complaints, and Winkworth Franchising said all offices are required to disclose AI imagery and must not misrepresent a property. The disclosure failure was attributed to a proofing error. Agency Howards subsequently announced a policy of labelling all AI-enhanced photos and stated it never uses AI to misrepresent fundamental features.

Savills and Knight Frank both confirmed AI image use in some listings, with Savills saying it shows two images for staged properties: the room as it is, and the AI version.

The Propertymark Position

Nathan Emerson, chief executive of Propertymark, has been consistent throughout the controversy. AI should "never be used to mislead buyers, create unrealistic expectations, or alter the condition or fundamental characteristics of a property." The Guild of Property Professionals has reinforced that agents remain responsible for their marketing whether a human or an algorithm produced it. That accountability point is not trivial: outsourcing the creative act to an AI tool does not outsource the legal liability.

A Sector Still Catching Up

The timing matters for a separate reason. A July 2026 survey of more than 340 self-managing landlords found 92% still running their lettings on spreadsheets or paper rather than dedicated software. If the sharp end of the market, the independent landlords and smaller agencies, has not yet built the digital discipline to manage compliance documentation, the assumption that they are carefully labelling AI-staged photography is optimistic at best.

That digital literacy gap shows up in trademark data too. AI Business Dispatch analysis of UK Intellectual Property Office trademark filings (IPO/TMD data, as of November 2026) recorded just 1,303 Class 36 filings in Q4 2026, down 42.3% on the prior period. Class 36 covers financial and real estate services; a sharp drop in brand-protection activity in the sector suggests many smaller operators are not yet thinking systematically about their digital footprint, let alone the regulatory compliance that comes with it.

What Agents Should Do Now

The operational ask from Trading Standards is not complicated. Label AI-enhanced images clearly, in legible text, in a position a consumer will actually see. Do not use AI to remove structural features, hide defects or manufacture a room that does not exist. Keep unedited originals. If a listing is flagged, the CMA is now the enforcement route, not the toothless complaint mechanisms of the NTSELAT era.

For agents who thought "virtually staged" buried in a footer was sufficient, this week's guidance is a reminder that the standard is the average consumer's impression, not the agent's intent.

housefishingAI property listingsDMCC ActTrading StandardsCMAWinkworthPropertymarkPropTechestate agentsconsumer protectionAI regulationvirtual staging